❌ The Menu Mistakes Draining Your Margins
A well-engineered menu can sharpen your brand and boost your bottom line without raising prices. Here’s how…
🌞 Welcome to this Week's Newsletter
Your menu could be a stronger tool in your marketing arsenal. In fact, research from the Journal of Tourism and Gastronomy Studies shows that well-engineered menus can increase profitability by up to 15%. Yet most menus grow by default: inherited templates, rushed updates, or ‘something for everyone’ bloat.
This guide explains how to apply psychology, structure, and data-driven insights to turn a passive menu into a strategic growth driver. Whether you’re running a single venue or managing multiple sites, menu engineering can sharpen your positioning, reduce friction, and raise profit, without raising your prices.
Are you ready to maximise your margins?
Let’s Check In ☕
📜 Menu Engineering 101
Menu engineering is a strategic process which influences customer choices to drive profitability. Combining pricing psychology, strategic positioning, tactical messaging and graphic design, restaurants can optimise their menus to guide diners toward high-margin items.
Menu engineering goes hand in hand with creating a strong brand, and when done correctly, this strategy enhances both the customer experience and your bottom line.
In fact, the biggest menu mistake is not engineering.
But before you can guide diners toward high-margin dishes, you need a menu that doesn’t make them want to give up halfway through. That’s where many restaurants go wrong. They don’t have an engineering problem, they have an overwhelm problem.
🤯 How Menu Complexity Undermines Profitability
Although it's great to present people with choices, there's a point where it becomes overwhelming for some when presented with too many options.
Menus that feel cluttered or unstructured confuse diners and distract from your brand story. A menu overloaded with options can weaken the connection between the customer and your restaurant’s identity. Instead of choosing a high-margin dish, customers may gravitate to familiar, low-margin options.
I once worked with a cafe with over 200 items on its menu. Their idea was clear, something for everyone. But the result was a confused kitchen, slower service, and guests who couldn’t tell what the business stood for.
You need to know which items are pulling their weight. That’s where the Cost Margin Analysis Model comes in.
📊 Cost Margin Analysis Model
A well-placed, high-profit dish can do much more for your revenue than one that’s tucked away.
The Cost Margin Analysis Model assesses each dish based on its contribution margin in the late 1970s; this concept aims to help restaurateurs optimise their menus and enhance profitability by analysing both the cost and popularity of menu items. This dual focus allows restaurants to move away from guesswork and make informed, data-driven decisions.
First, you need to calculate the profit margins for each dish. Start by calculating each dish's Cost of Goods Sold (COGS), including the ingredients and supplies used to make it. COGS does not include overheads, staff costs, or other operating expenses like rent, utilities, or marketing.
Use this simple formula to calculate the profit margin for each dish:
Profit Margin = Selling Price - COGS
For example, if a dish costs £5 to make and sells for £20, the monetary margin would be: £20 - £5 = £15
If you prefer a statistical approach:
Profit Margin = (Selling Price - COGS) ÷ Selling Price × 100
For example, if a dish costs £5 to make and sells for £20, the profit margin would be:
(£20 - £5) ÷ £20 × 100 = 75%
This method allows you to track dish profitability over time.
Once you have calculated your margins, you can start categorising menu items within the Menu Engineering Matrix:
Stars: High sales and high-profit margins. These dishes usually have a profit margin of 60% or higher and are your top sellers. They drive revenue and should be promoted heavily.
Plough Horses: High sales but lower profit margins. These dishes typically have a profit margin of 30% to 50%. While they sell well, they may need a price adjustment or cost management to improve profitability.
Puzzles: High profit margins but low sales. These dishes have a profit margin of 50% or higher but sell less frequently. Consider promoting them more to increase visibility and sales.
Dogs: Low sales and low-profit margins. These dishes generally have a profit margin of under 30% and are low performers. These dishes may need to be reworked, re-priced, or removed from the menu altogether.
Your final matrix may look something like this…
In Leslie’s Cafe, dishes like Avocado Toast and Flat Whites sit in the Star quadrant—they’re profitable, popular, and brand-aligned. The Plough Horses, such as the Full English and Chocolate Fudge Cake, are beloved staples but costlier to produce. Items like Quiche Lorraine and Macaroons are Puzzles they carry good margins but don’t sell often, so their position needs rethinking. Then there are the Dogs, menu bloating items like Prawn Linguine or Spaghetti Carbonara, added in a panic to boost sales. They don’t fit the brand, rarely sell, and cost more than they earn. The more Dogs on your menu, the more they drag everything down.
Now that you’ve categorised your items, it's time to look at strategic menu design.
